DefendOpinion

Revisiting the Primary Arms ACSS Vulcan Reticle

Some folks love the Primary Arms ACSS Vulcan reticle, others hate it. Me? I have a love-hate relationship with it, but more often than not it errs on the side of love for the benefits it can provide.

7 min read Updated
Holosun 507K X2 with the ACSS Vulcan Dot on a Sig Sauer pistol slide, in front of its box

When it comes to pistol mounted optics, I frequently recommend Holosun optics. While they are inexpensive, they have earned a reputation as a reliable and durable optic. The reputation is well deserved, and they have kept improving since I first became aware of them. They take a beating. The glass is decent. And the price is right. Almost without fail, folks then ask, “Which reticle option is the best?” They are after all available with just a dot, the beloved by many “doughnut of death”, and the Primary Arms ACSS Vulcan reticle. That question is difficult to answer because it depends entirely on the individual asking the question.

A reticle choice that depends on the user rather than the application might seem counterintuitive. I’d argue that it should. That doesn’t make it untrue, and it’s where I’m at with it today.

Last time I wrote about the ACSS Vulcan reticle, I mentioned that I had been on the fence about it. After some time with it, I had no reservations about recommending it on slimline pistols for defensive carry. That still holds true, but how I recommend using it has become more nuanced.

What the ACSS Vulcan Reticle Is

Back of a Holosun box explaining the ACSS Vulcan reticle: a chevron inside a large outer ring, with diagrams of the ring showing when the sight is aimed too high, low, left or right

It’s a dot (or a chevron on the 507C Holosun optic) surrounded by a rather large ring (a 230 MOA ring in the case of the 507K Holosun optic). You can’t see the ring when the aiming reference (the dot or the chevron) is visible in the window. The ring is for when the aiming reference is not on the lens. If the pistol is more or less aligned with the target, the outer circle shows you which way to correct.

The Case Against the Ring

Some folks view this correction reference as a crutch, and I agree with that. In my opinion, the crutch can be a good thing. Others have suggested that the crutch lets users of the reticle remain lazy about perfecting their indexes and presentation. Another group suggests the crutch can get in the way of developing target focus and can be detrimental to shot placement in certain situations. I agree with all that as well. The points are all plausible and valid.

However, those opinions often come from a place of projection. They assume that other users either have the same skill level, or aspire to the same skill level, as the individual expressing the opinion. Again, I don’t think any of the opinions are blatantly incorrect. Rather, the opinions aren’t globally applicable.

Why I Turned Mine Off

Take me for instance. My skill level has changed since I last wrote about the ACSS reticle. While I have a couple of pistols with mounted optics that feature the reticle, I have turned off the outer ring on all of them. I’ve also turned off the ring on the “doughnut of death” optics I have mounted. This is because I have, for the most part, sorted out my presentation. The plain old center dot is now the aiming reference most conducive to essentially everything that I do with a pistol at my current skill level. Does that mean that I’m encouraging everyone to only use the simple dot on their pistol mounted optics today? Nope. Not even close. I’m only saying that the reticle configurations don’t work as well for me as the simple dots do. But that’s just me. And you’re not me. Nor am I you.

This is dangerously close to sounding like a “works for me” argument, but it’s not. At least, I don’t think it is.

Training Wheels for the Presentation

I found the outer ring of the ACSS reticle to be useful in my practice when I was working on my presentation. If my presentation wasn’t good, then the ring let me know what I needed to do to correct it. Once my presentation was good and I was “finding the dot”, I turned the outer ring off and continued to practice without it. This, I think, is a fantastic use of the reticle.

There are some who will disagree with me, because this form of presentation development drives folks to become reticle or dot focused in practice when they should be working on becoming target focused. Again, they aren’t wrong. It can lead folks to become dot focused, which is suboptimal. However, you can mitigate that to an extent by occluding the front lens. It’s also very hard to train and practice target focus when you can’t find the dot. In this sense, I think that the ACSS reticle may be a good option for those who aspire to a high level of marksmanship with optic mounted pistols but still haven’t developed a consistent presentation. However, it’s important to get rid of the training wheels (the outer ring) as soon as possible.

Holosun 507C X2 with the ACSS Vulcan reticle on a black pistol slide, leaning against its box on a tan range bag

Where the Ring Helps in Recoil

I also found the ACSS reticle design to be useful when shooting small slimline pistols, which tend to have a lot more muzzle rise than full size pistols. As I explained last time, the reticle gave me an idea of the direction the aiming reference was moving when it left the window and informed me when it was returning. I found this to be very beneficial when the target difficulty required a finer grained visual confirmation before sending each shot.

Detractors of the reticle will sometimes argue that this is unnecessary and will only slow down the next shot. It takes additional cognitive load to make sure you are reacting to the aiming reference and not the outer circle. Once again, that’s a valid point. However, even those who have developed a grip that allows for consistent recoil recovery sometimes screw up the grip, and then recoil recovery isn’t consistent. When that happens, the outer ring once again provides a valuable correction reference. Is that correction reference worth the additional cognitive load prior to taking a shot? I’d argue that it is for novice to intermediate level marksmen, since the corrective reference decreases the muzzle to target realignment time. This is probably not the case for highly skilled advanced marksmen who very rarely experience a bad grip and inconsistent recoil recovery.

See where I’m going with this yet?

Who Should Use It

The outer ring, which can be turned on or off, can be a valuable aid. Sure, it can also be a crutch that enables laziness. It can be an additional input that places unnecessary tax on the pistolero. And it can lead to false positive shoot indicators for advanced marksmen who rely on very coarse grained color based visual confirmation.

Holosun 507K X2 with the ACSS Vulcan Dot on a Sig Sauer pistol slide, in front of its box

That probably sounds like more cons than pros, but a thing I’ve learned over the years is that there are several types of gun owners who put optics on their pistols such as, but not limited to:

  • Those who have no aspirations to become skilled marksmen and will rarely practice (the ACSS reticle is a great option here),
  • those who have aspirations to become skilled marksmen, but won’t do the work for one reason or another (the ACSS reticle is a great option here as well),
  • those who have aspirations and are training, but are still in the early stages of their skill development (the ACSS reticle is a good option here if it is used judiciously and wisely),
  • and those who truly are advanced marksmen (the reticle won’t matter for folks in this category).

Closing Thoughts

So what’s the best Holosun optic reticle for you? It depends.

If you’re just starting down the red dot path, the Primary Arms ACSS Vulcan reticle is, in my opinion, a safe bet and worth consideration. Already on your way to becoming a competent marksman? I still suggest considering it, but work towards turning off the outer ring and not relying on it. If you are an IDPA Expert or USPSA B class pistolero or better, then you probably realize that the reticle matters very little. Still, having an optional corrective aid for some situations and contexts might be worth your while.

Your pistol, your skill level, your call.

Filed under ◆ ◆ ◆

Most Read

Latest