Every fall, somewhere around the first cold front, the same search for 6.5 Creedmoor hunting ammo lands a few hundred of y’all on a post I wrote in the summer of 2019: the Battle of the 6.5 Creedmoor Factory Hunting Loads. It’s a decent post. It’s also seven years old, and it ends with a verdict I didn’t follow. So before deer season opens on November 7, I owe everyone the rest of the story. What I actually loaded, what it did to deer, and what it costs me per season.
This Isn’t a Group Test
Let’s get that out of the way. Back in 2019 I shot four-shot groups at 100 yards with six different loads, let the barrel cool between strings, and measured everything with calipers. I don’t do that anymore, and I’m not going to pretend I did it for this post. Group testing is tedious, and without a lead sled the biggest variable in every group is me. I said as much in 2019, and nothing since has changed my mind. I’m also not going to shoot ballistic gel. It’s expensive, and folks with better equipment and more patience have already covered the ELD-X in gel from every angle you could want.
What I have instead is six seasons of hunting with one load out of one rifle. Zero checks, shots at game, what happened on the other end. For the question most of y’all are actually asking, which is “what 6.5 Creedmoor hunting ammo should I buy for deer season,” I think that record is worth more than another set of groups.
How I Picked My 6.5 Creedmoor Hunting Ammo
The rifle is a Fierce Firearms Fury LR in 6.5 Creedmoor that I bought in the spring of 2019 because I didn’t like shooting the .30-06 bolt gun I took my first deer with. It weighs 7.2 lb, came with a brake, and these days wears a SilencerCo Harvester 300 and a Vortex Optics Razor HD LHT 4.5-22×50 FFP. Fierce guarantees half-MOA. I have never been able to hold the rifle to that, and I’ve made my peace with it.
The 2019 Test: Six 6.5 Creedmoor Hunting Loads
That summer I did the sensible thing and tested six factory hunting loads before picking one. The Hornady Precision Hunter 143 gr ELD-X shot the single best group of the whole exercise, 0.3615 in, and the second-worst average, 0.9543 in with a standard deviation of 0.4773 in. Federal Fusion was the consistent one: a 0.7246 in average with a 0.1720 in standard deviation. So on September 2, 2019, I settled on Fusion. “At least for this season,” I wrote, and then I spent two more paragraphs talking myself back toward the Hornady. One footnote from 2026: Ballistic-X, an app I didn’t know existed in 2019, calls that same best group 0.432 in with a mean radius of 0.184 in. My calipers were generous. The ranking stands because every load got the same calipers, and either number is under half an MOA.
The Switch to the ELD-X
Two months later I was sitting in a blind on opening weekend with Precision Hunter in the magazine. Here’s what happened in between.
In 2019 I had caught the long-range bug, and anything with a high ballistic coefficient had my full attention. Hornady’s ELD bullets were the hot name in that world, and as far as I can tell they still are. The ELD-X carries a 0.625 G1 against the Fusion’s soft point, the property had deer standing at 225 to 250 yards, and I was a new hunter who had never shot at game past 100. Less drop and less drift meant less arithmetic for me to get wrong, and that sub-half-MOA group wouldn’t leave me alone. The test said Fusion. The hunter picked Hornady. The Fusion never made it to the blind.
One Box of ELD-X a Year
Here’s my whole 6.5 Creedmoor hunting ammo budget for a season: one 20-round box, and I rarely get through it. A few days before the first hunt I take the rifle to the local indoor range, which has a 100-yard lane. Indoors takes weather and wind out of the equation, so the conditions are the same season after season, and that makes the check meaningful. Five rounds to confirm zero. In six seasons it has never moved. That leaves 15 for the hunt, and a good season uses about six of them. A season with no shot uses none.
Why Nothing Else Got Tried
I want to be honest about why nothing else ever got tried, because it isn’t a glowing endorsement so much as the absence of a reason. The rifle has never failed to feed or fire a Precision Hunter round. The zero has never surprised me on a hunt. I’ve never had a flyer I could blame on the ammunition rather than on the guy behind it.
After that first season I bought a 200-round case, ten boxes of 20, so I haven’t shopped for the stuff since 2019 and slept right through the 2020 to 2022 shortage. At five rounds to confirm and six on a good season, a case is roughly 20 seasons of ammunition, and light seasons stretch it further. Counting for this post, six full boxes and one missing a single round are still on the shelf, 139 rounds from that first case. Going through the ammo cabinet also turned up a second case I’d forgotten buying. Call it 30 seasons of hunting ammo, give or take. When a load does its job every single time you ask, the next box you open is the same box. That’s how seven years go by.
What the ELD-X Costs
The cost is the part that stung in 2019 and stings a little more now. I paid $34.50 for 20 rounds then, and the same box runs about $38 today at the best price I can find, call it $1.90 a round. That’s the expensive end of the shelf for 6.5 Creedmoor hunting ammo. Run the math on how few rounds a season actually burns, though, and it gets hard to care. Six seasons of zero checks plus every shot in the table below comes to about 40 rounds. At today’s box price that’s about $76 of ammunition for four deer, or under $20 a deer. I spend more than that on corn.
For what it’s worth, the 200-round case was cheaper per box than singles when I bought it in 2019, which is why I bought it. As I write this the deals site shows the opposite, with singles the better buy. That flips with sales and the market, so check both before you order.
The ELD-X on Deer
This is the table I wish the 2019 series had ended with. Every shot I’ve taken at game with this 6.5 Creedmoor hunting ammo, as best I can reconstruct it, including the ones I’d rather not talk about.
| Season | Animal | Distance | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2019 opener | Whitetail (a spike, it turned out) | ~225 yd | Vital hit, dropped within 10 yd |
| 2019 opener | Whitetail (another spike) | ~250 yd | Vital hit, dropped |
| 2019 opener | Whitetail | ~260 yd | Hit low, long track, not recovered |
| 2019, late season | Whitetail | ~150 yd (best guess) | Dropped |
| 2020 | None | – | Axis hunt, no shot taken |
| 2021 to 2023 | None | – | Hunted, no shots taken (the drought) |
| Dec 2024 | Doe | 200 yd | Dropped where she stood |
The Shots That Went Wrong
About that third row. On the 2019 opener I pulled a shot low on a deer at about 260 yards, watched it hit, and then compounded the mistake with a rushed follow-up as the deer ran for the tree line. We tracked it for a long time and never found it. That one is on me, not the bullet, and I’ve carried it ever since.
Later that same day I missed twice more on deer I’d ranged at 320 yards. Turns out I’d lased the grass behind them. The real distance was somewhere around 200, and my holdover put both rounds over their backs. Rangefinders are only as good as the thing you point them at, which is why I now estimate the distance with the reticle first and then confirm it with the laser. Measure twice, cut once. I bring these up because a post that only lists the deer that dropped isn’t a record. It’s a brochure.
The Drought and the Doe
Then there’s the gap. The 2020 axis hunt ended without a shot, and from 2021 through 2023 I hunted when I could and never got a shot I was allowed to take, which is a story about Texas lease prices and property rules rather than ammunition. The drought broke in December 2024, when a doe at 200 yards took the ELD-X through the vitals and folded like somebody had cut the strings. That’s the kind of result that makes a hunter stop thinking about ammunition altogether. In 2025 I sat out entirely. The same arthritis flare that benched me from matches kept me off the range and out of the blind.
What the ELD-X Does on Impact
On Texas whitetail, at these distances, it usually goes through. Most of the deer in that table had an entry and an exit, and the damaged meat around both has been modest enough that the processor trims it and moves on. Once the bullet didn’t make it out. I found it while quartering, stopped by a rib on the exit side after doing its work, and I didn’t photograph it, which I regret. I’d have sworn I had a picture, but the recovered bullet I do have a photo of is a Federal Fusion from a .308, out of a different rifle on a different hunt.
That one ELD-X looked like the catalog picture: expanded wide, mushroomed evenly, jacket and core still together. No jacket separation, no fragments wandering off on their own. Nothing I’ve seen on a carcass has given me a reason to second-guess the bullet. The only marginal results in six seasons were the two I sent over their backs and the one I put too low, and the common factor there wasn’t the load.
Where It Falls Short
Price
If you shoot your deer rifle the way I shoot pistols, a couple thousand rounds a year, this is not the load for you, and neither is any other premium 6.5 Creedmoor hunting ammo. Buy something cheap to practice with and keep the good stuff for the season. At my volume the premium is a rounding error. And to be fair to Hornady, part of the sting is the cartridge, not the load. The 6.5 Creedmoor costs more than a .308 Winchester out of the same action size because fewer people shoot it. That’s supply and demand, and no box of ammo is going to fix it.
Twenty-Round Boxes
Hornady sells Precision Hunter in boxes of 20, which is fine for the way I use it and annoying for anyone who wants to practice with the same load they hunt with. Beyond that, nothing to date has given me pause. I keep waiting for the catch and it hasn’t shown up.
Why I Won’t Reload the ELD-X
The reloading question comes up every time, so here it is. I started handloading in 2025 and I now run a Dillon XL750 for 9mm, so in theory I could load the ELD-X bullet myself the way 2019 Zo threatened to. In practice I burn a dozen rounds of 6.5 Creedmoor in a good year,and the two cases on the shelf have decades in them. The dies, the brass, and the load development would never pay for themselves, and I’d be hunting with a load that has 20 rounds of history instead of six seasons.
When those cases finally run dry, I’ll buy another one. The only thing that would change that is getting into precision rifle competition, which is possible but unlikely, and even then I doubt I’d pick the 6.5 Creedmoor. I’d be tempted by one of the cartridges the pros are actually running, and that’s a different rifle and a different post.
The Good
4
- Flat enough that 250 yd is a hold, not a project
- Zero that hasn’t moved in six seasons
- Drops deer when I do my part, usually with an exit
- Never a feeding or ignition issue
The Bad
2
- The priciest box on the shelf
- Twenty rounds to a box
The Ugly
1
- The 2019 deer I didn’t recover (my fault, not the load’s)
Closing Thoughts
If you came here from a search for the best 6.5 Creedmoor hunting ammo, I can’t tell you what’s best. I can tell you what I stopped testing and started hunting with, and that six seasons later I have no reason to change. The Hornady Precision Hunter 143 gr ELD-X does what a deer load is supposed to do: it goes where the rifle is pointed, it arrives with enough left to matter, and it has never once been the reason a hunt went sideways. The reasons were all me, and I’ve written them down above so you don’t have to take my word for the good parts. Four of the seven deer I’ve ever taken fell to this load. The other three were a whitetail with a .30-06 and two axis with a .308.
Where I’m hunting this November is still up in the air, and there’s a real chance the 6mm ARC gets the nod over the Creedmoor this year. More on that rifle soon. Either way there’s a fresh box on the bench, and unless the ARC grows on me or some other load tickles my fancy, this is what I’ll keep hunting with for the foreseeable future. I’d like to hear from y’all, though: what load did you quit testing and just go hunting with?
Comments